LATEST NEWS: Further updates on the amendments to the Public Contracts Code: the new measures regarding alternative dispute resolution

Articles16 November 2026

Decree-Law No. 177/2026 of 4 September, which came into force on 1 October 2026, carried out a comprehensive revision of the Public Contracts Code. It introduced significant changes to the regime governing arbitration and other means of alternative dispute resolution arising from the formation and performance of public contracts, replacing the previous provisions set out in Article 476 of the Public Contracts Code (repealed) with the introduction of a new chapter, in Part IV of the Code, entitled ‘Alternative dispute resolution for pre-contractual and contractual disputes’ and comprising Articles 464-B to 464-G.

It aimed to bring the arbitration regime in public procurement into line with that of the CPTA, to overcome issues of constitutionality and compliance with European Union law, and to promote consensual and expeditious forms of dispute resolution.

This legislation expressly and exceptionally provided that the amendments relating to alternative dispute resolution also apply to proceedings already in progress and to contracts in force on the date of the legislation’s entry into force, thereby permitting their immediate application to procedural and contractual relationships already established.

The previous Article 476 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) provided that recourse to arbitration or other means of alternative dispute resolution was permitted for disputes arising from proceedings or contracts subject to the CCP. However, it was not limited to merely permitting the admissibility of arbitration. Where the contracting authority opted for this solution, it had to comply with a significant set of requirements: i. the acceptance, by all interested parties, candidates and tenderers, of the jurisdiction of an institutionalised arbitration centre for disputes relating to the contract award procedure; ii. a provision in the tender documents and the contract requiring the contracting party to accept the jurisdiction of that centre for contractual disputes; iii. the definition of the procedure for constituting the arbitral tribunal and the applicable procedural rules, by reference to the rules of the competent institutionalised arbitration centre; iv. the requirement to justify the use of an arbitral tribunal not affiliated with an institutionalised arbitration centre, in particular on the grounds of legal or technical complexity, the economic value of the dispute, the absence of a competent centre, greater delays or higher costs; v. the preparation of a cost impact assessment where a non-institutionalised arbitral tribunal is chosen; and vi. the possibility of appealing to the competent administrative court in disputes involving amounts exceeding €500,000. The previous model was thus based on arbitration pre-determined by the contracting authority: arbitration was permitted, but its acceptance was imposed on economic operators, which undermined its voluntary nature, particularly when the operators had no real room for negotiation.

With the repeal of Article 476 of the Code of Civil Procedure, a separate chapter was created within the Code, setting out four points: i. a general principle of the admissibility of arbitration and other means of alternative dispute resolution; ii. a specific regime for arbitration; iii. a procedure for the prevention and amicable resolution of disputes through technical conciliation committees; and iv. a mechanism to safeguard limitation and expiry periods whilst conciliation is being attempted.

Article 464-B provides that recourse to arbitration or other alternative dispute resolution methods is permitted, in accordance with the law, for disputes arising from public procurement procedures and contracts subject to the CCP. Article 464-C provides that arbitral tribunals may be constituted to resolve disputes arising from procedures or contracts covered by the Public Contracts Code.

The main change compared with the previous regime lies in the way arbitration is structured in the pre-contractual procedure. Where the contracting authority intends to refer disputes arising from the formation of the contract to arbitration, it must specify in the tender documents or in the invitation to tender: i. the arbitration centre where the tribunal will sit; ii. the applicable procedural rules, where the centre’s rules are not fully available on its website; and iii. the requirement for candidates or tenderers to accept recourse to arbitration, in accordance with the model set out in Annex XII to the Public Procurement Code.

However, Article 464-C(3) provides that a candidate’s or tenderer’s refusal to accept arbitration does not entail the exclusion of their application or tender. This provision is central. The contracting authority may propose or provide for arbitration, but may not impose acceptance of the arbitral jurisdiction, nor may it stipulate that refusal thereof shall lead to the economic operator’s exclusion from the procedure. The difference compared with the repealed Article 476 is significant, as the latter required acceptance by all interested parties, candidates and tenderers, without establishing, in the wording then in force, a safeguard equivalent to that now enshrined in Article 464-C(3), which meant that a tenderer’s refusal to accept the submission of disputes to arbitration could be grounds for their exclusion from the procedure.

The new regime also removes the specific conditions that previously restricted recourse to arbitral tribunals not affiliated with institutionalised centres, as well as the obligation to carry out a cost impact assessment of that choice. The special rule concerning appeals against arbitral awards in disputes involving sums in excess of €500,000 has also been abolished. The removal of these requirements simplifies the regime, but also shifts the determination of various aspects – which were previously expressly regulated in the CCP – to general arbitration legislation and the CPTA.

In the procedures for the formation of contracts provided for in Article 100(1) of the CPTA, the requirement remains that the rules governing the functioning of the arbitral tribunal must comply with the regime for urgent pre-contractual proceedings. The reform does not, therefore, eliminate the need to ensure compatibility between the arbitral proceedings and the specific requirements of urgent pre-contractual relief.

The most significant innovation in the legislation is the possibility of establishing technical conciliation committees. Article 464-D provides that any party to a public or administrative contract may request the establishment of a technical conciliation committee to prevent or resolve contractual disputes; the members of such a committee, appointed by the parties, must possess technical qualifications or professional experience appropriate to the subject matter of the dispute. This committee may intervene not only once a dispute has already arisen, but also at a pre-litigation stage where there is a disagreement likely to jeopardise the performance of the contract. It can be a highly effective means of dispute resolution, for example, in public works contracts, which are particularly prone to problems arising during their performance, and where the resolution of such issues is incompatible with the slowness of the administrative courts.

This conciliation procedure begins with a request addressed to the other party, setting out the facts and the grounds for the request. The respondent has 10 days to reply and to nominate a member of the Commission. The conciliation hearing must take place within a maximum of 15 days from the end of the response period, unless postponed for a justified reason. The hearing may be held in person or via electronic means. The Commission must carry out a careful examination of the matter and seek to reach an agreement between the parties. Notifications and summonses are issued electronically. The procedure is thus characterised by i. informality, as only the essential elements of the application and the key deadlines are specified; ii. speed, through the setting of short deadlines for responses and for holding the hearing; iii. technical expertise, given the qualifications and experience of the commission members; and iv. technological flexibility, through the use of electronic means for hearings and notifications.

It is also permitted to lay down specific contractual rules governing the conciliation process, with statutory rules serving as a fallback and applying in the absence of specific contractual provisions, thereby allowing the parties to tailor the procedure in advance to the complexity, duration and technical nature of the contract.

If the conciliation attempt is successful, a record is drawn up, which must set out all the terms and conditions of the agreement. The legislation does not specify the enforceable nature of this record, nor does it establish a framework regarding its binding force or the mechanisms for the compulsory enforcement of the agreement, which may give rise to uncertainties as to its practical effectiveness and, for example, as to whether or not it requires judicial or arbitral approval.

One of the most significant safeguards under the new regime is set out in Article 464-G. The application for a conciliation attempt suspends the limitation periods for rights and the time-barring of legal or arbitral proceedings. These time limits resume 30 days after the applicant is notified that conciliation cannot be carried out or is unfeasible. This provision seeks to prevent the use of a consensual process from prejudicing the position of the party initiating it. Without this suspensive effect, the party might be faced with an unreasonable choice: to initiate legal or arbitral proceedings immediately to preserve its rights, or to attempt an amicable settlement whilst running the risk of allowing a limitation or expiry period to lapse. The solution adopted encourages the effective use of conciliation because it reduces the risk associated with attempting to reach an agreement. At the same time, the legislator does not provide for an indefinite suspension of time limits: it sets an objective point in time for their resumption, 30 days after notification of the unfeasibility or impossibility of conciliation.

Among the advantages of this reform is the fact that it is no longer possible to exclude a tenderer for refusing to accept arbitration, which constitutes an important safeguard against the arbitration clause being transformed into a materially mandatory requirement for access to the public procurement procedure. Another advantage is the creation of a general conciliation mechanism, with the possibility for either party to request the establishment of a technical committee, comprising qualified individuals and operating within short timeframes, which can be very useful in contracts of high technical complexity, where a consensual solution is preferable to the suspension of contractual performance or the immediate initiation of legal or arbitration proceedings. Finally, the suspension of limitation and expiry periods constitutes an essential safeguard for the party seeking to resolve the dispute by mutual agreement. Without this mechanism, conciliation might theoretically be encouraged, but in practice it would be discouraged.

There are, however, some issues that remain unresolved. First and foremost, the relationship between the new regime and contracts already entered into. As the amendments relating to alternative dispute resolution are intended to apply to ongoing proceedings and contracts currently in force, difficulties may arise where the contract contains a jurisdiction clause, an arbitration agreement or a dispute resolution procedure that is incompatible with the new regime. With regard to the legal effects of the conciliation award, the agreement is required to be formalised in a written award, but the rules governing its enforceability are not specified. It will be necessary to assess, on a case-by-case basis, whether the agreement can serve as an enforceable instrument, whether it is subject to judicial approval, or whether it must be converted into a formal contractual amendment, particularly where changes to contractual obligations, prices or deadlines are involved. Finally, the removal of the special rule on appeals against arbitral awards in contracts worth more than €500,000 requires an analysis in conjunction with the CPTA and general arbitration legislation, and may narrow the range of situations in which an appeal is possible.

This reform promotes a swifter and technically sounder resolution of disputes, but its effectiveness will depend on the challenging task of harmonising it with existing arbitration agreements and contracts, as well as with the regime governing the enforcement of conciliation agreements.

Dos peatones caminan por una calle adoquinada flanqueada por edificios históricos, mientras circulan coches y furgonetas y se ve un arco al fondo.

Related professionals

LATEST FROM #ECIJA