LATEST NEWS: Algorithms under strict liability: insurance in a race against time

Articles17 November 2026

A smart vacuum cleaner that, following an update, causes a fire. A health app that deletes years’ worth of personal records. An artificial intelligence system that ‘learns’ dangerous behaviour. Until now, those who suffered such damage found it very difficult to obtain compensation. The new Directive (EU) 2024/2853 on liability for defective products changes this situation for products placed on the market or put into service after 9 December 2026.


The first major change is simple: software is now expressly classified as a ‘product’. The same applies to digital manufacturing files and related services, that is, the digital services without which the product does not function as intended. Only free and open-source software, developed outside the scope of a commercial activity, is excluded. The manufacturer is therefore liable for any damage caused by their software, even in the absence of fault; in certain cases, the importer, authorised representative or distributor may also be held liable.


The second new provision concerns defects: a product is defective if it does not offer the safety that can legitimately be expected. In assessing this safety, factors such as the product’s ability to continue learning after it has been sold and compliance with cybersecurity requirements are taken into account. The manufacturer remains liable for as long as it retains control over the product, in particular through updates. Thus, a cyber-attack exploiting a cybersecurity vulnerability in the product does not, in itself, absolve the manufacturer of liability.


The range of compensable damages has also been expanded. In addition to death, personal injury and damage to property, it now includes clinically recognised psychological harm and the destruction or corruption of data not used for professional purposes. Lost family photographs or personal documents are no longer losses for which no compensation is available.


The most profound change lies in the area of evidence. Proving that an algorithm has failed is almost impossible for anyone unfamiliar with how it works.

Therefore, the injured party may ask the court to order the company to produce the relevant evidence, whilst safeguarding trade secrets; if the company fails to do so, a defect is presumed. Furthermore, where technical complexity makes proving the case excessively difficult, the defect and the causal link may be presumed, and it is sufficient for the injured party to demonstrate that they are probable. These presumptions may be rebutted by the companies, on whom the burden of proof lies to demonstrate the contrary. Furthermore, liability towards the injured party cannot be contractually limited or excluded.


The injured party has three years to bring a claim, counted from the moment they became aware, or ought reasonably to have become aware, of the damage, the defect and the identity of the liable party. In any event, unless legal proceedings have been brought in the meantime, the right to compensation lapses ten years after the product was placed on the market or put into service; if the product is substantially modified, this period runs from the date of the modification. Exceptionally, the time limit is extended to twenty-five years where a latent personal injury has prevented the injured party from bringing proceedings.


For businesses and insurers, the consequences are immediate. Many product liability insurance policies still assume physical goods and exclude ‘data’ or ‘cyber acts’, which may leave the risks that the new Directive places on the manufacturer uncovered. For their part, cyber-risk policies often cover only the insured’s own losses, and not their liability towards third parties. The European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA) warns against ‘silent’ cover – provisions that are neither expressly included nor excluded – and recommends clear cover and exclusions. Without careful coordination between the two policies, gaps only become apparent when a claim is made.


The deadline for transposing the Directive is 9 December 2026, the date from which the new regime will apply to products placed on the market or put into service. Until then, manufacturers, importers, distributors, online platforms and companies that integrate software into their products must analyse the impact of these rules on their business, review contracts with suppliers and procedures for retaining technical documentation, and reassess their civil liability and cyber risk insurance policies.

Primer plano de varias bombillas rojas encendidas que reflejan destellos sobre una superficie roja.

Related professionals

LATEST FROM #ECIJA