LATEST NEWS: Constitutional Court paves the way for capital gains tax refunds on the sale of homes built with building loans
In a judgment of 7 April 2026, the Constitutional Court ruled that the interpretation which excludes from the capital gains tax exemption scheme situations where the proceeds from the sale of a property are used to repay a loan taken out to build the house, and not merely for its purchase. The decision may pave the way for the recovery of tax paid by taxpayers in similar circumstances.
This decision may have a very significant impact on taxpayers who built their own permanent home using a building loan and who were subject to personal income tax on capital gains between 2015 and 2020.
1. Background and issue under discussion
The special scheme provided for in Article 11 of Law No. 82-E/2014 of 31 December (known as the transitional regime for capital gains on property), allowed capital gains realised on the sale of one’s own permanent residence to be exempt from taxation where the proceeds of the sale were used to repay the loan taken out to purchase the property.
This scheme applied to disposals taking place between 2015 and 2020, provided that the loan agreements had been entered into by 31 December 2014. The stated aim of this scheme was to provide relief to families in financial difficulty, whose incomes were no longer sufficient to cover their housing costs, by ensuring that the sale of their home to repay the loan was not further penalised by capital gains tax.
However, until the recent decision by the Constitutional Court, the Tax Authority and the courts – including the Supreme Administrative Court – had been interpreting this scheme restrictively: the exemption from taxation only applied when the proceeds of the sale were used to repay loans taken out to purchase the property being sold, excluding cases where the loan had been taken out to build the property.
The case brought before the Constitutional Court arose from a personal income tax assessment relating to the year 2016. The Tax Authority took the view that there was no basis for the capital gains tax exemption, despite the fact that the proceeds from the sale of the house had been used in full to repay the bank loan that had financed the construction of that owner-occupied and permanent residence. This interpretation was upheld by the Supreme Administrative Court.
2. Decision of the Constitutional Court
The Constitutional Court held that treating those who purchased a house using a mortgage differently from those who built it using a building loan, when both sell the property and use the proceeds of the sale to repay their respective loans, violates the constitutional principles of equality, substantive justice and the ability to pay.
In the Constitutional Court’s view, the two situations are, in substance, equivalent: in both cases, the taxpayer used a bank loan to acquire their own permanent home, and sells the property using the proceeds to repay the loan. To that extent, this Court held that there are insufficient substantive grounds to impose a heavier tax burden on those who chose to build their own home.
The Court further considered that the measure adopted by the legislature (to exclude construction loans entirely) does not comply with the principle of proportionality, being manifestly excessive in relation to the alleged objective of preventing fraud.
Consequently, the Court declared Article 11(1) of Law No 82-E/2014 to be unconstitutional when interpreted as not covering the repayment of loans for the construction of one’s own permanent home.
3. Who may be affected
This decision is particularly relevant to taxpayers who meet all of the following requirements:
- The property sold is in fact their own permanent home (the place where they resided on a stable and continuous basis);
- The property was built (and not purchased ready-built) using a bank loan (building loan);
- The sale of the property took place between 1 January 2015 and 31 December 2020;
- The building loan agreement was entered into by 31 December 2014;
- The proceeds from the sale were used, in whole or in large part, to repay the building loan;
- The Tax Authority levied capital gains tax under the personal income tax scheme on the grounds that the exemption scheme did not apply, as the loan was for construction (and not for purchase).
The decision in question was handed down in a specific appeal and does not have generally binding effect – that is to say, it is not binding in all cases. However, it represents a clear and well-reasoned interpretation by the Constitutional Court of how the scheme in question should be interpreted in accordance with the Constitution. It is expected to influence the approach taken by the courts and the Tax Authority in similar cases.
Depending on each taxpayer’s specific circumstances, different courses of action may be available. It is essential to assess the situation with specialist legal advice:
- Whether there are any pending complaints, judicial challenges or appeals that might directly benefit from this ruling by the Constitutional Court;
- Whether the mechanism for ex officio review of tax assessments applies, which allows assessments to be reviewed even outside the normal time limits for challenge, in cases of error attributable to the tax authorities or serious and manifest injustice;
- Whether it is possible to raise a claim of unconstitutionality in pending proceedings, based on this judgment.
Given the complexity of the matter and the importance of procedural deadlines, we recommend that taxpayers who fit the profile described contact our Tax Law team, which is available to answer any queries and provide a tailored analysis of their situation. This analysis will enable us to assess the feasibility of taking action, the appropriate procedural avenues, and the associated costs and risks, thereby facilitating an informed decision.
