LATEST NEWS: The Problem of Overestimating Earnings in Compensation for Road Traffic Accident Victims

Articles17 July 2026

The calculation of compensation for road traffic accidents has, for decades, been one of the most hotly debated topics in Portuguese legal theory and case law. In practice, the assessment of future financial losses has been based almost exclusively on the victim’s loss of earnings, which has led to significant inequalities and a structural injustice that must be analysed and rectified.


Historically, the disability scales for work-related accidents and occupational diseases have served as the main reference for calculating compensation, even outside the workplace context. However, as clarified in the preamble to Decree-Law No. 352/2007 (which approves the National Table of Incapacity for Work-Related Accidents and Occupational Diseases and also the Indicative Table for the Assessment of Incapacity in Civil Law), assessment under labour law measures the loss of earning capacity, whilst under civil law what must be assessed is the overall permanent incapacity — that is, limitations on everyday activities, without prejudice to consideration of the repercussions on the injured party’s specific professional activity.


The inappropriate transposition of labour law criteria into the field of civil law has had serious consequences: victims on low incomes — students, the unemployed, pensioners, and informal workers — saw their injuries systematically undervalued, whilst others on higher wages received much higher compensation for injuries of an identical nature.


It is in this context that the concept of ‘biological damage’ emerged, influenced by Italian legal doctrine and case law. From the 1970s onwards, the Italian courts began to recognise that harm to an individual’s psychophysical integrity, as a constitutionally protected right, constitutes a form of damage eligible for compensation in its own right, irrespective of its impact on income from employment. This understanding was definitively enshrined in Judgment No. 184 of the Italian Constitutional Court, dated 14 July 1986, which affirmed the autonomy of this type of damage as an intermediate category between pecuniary damage and non-pecuniary damage.


In Portugal, the concept has been gradually adopted, albeit not without some hesitation. The publication of Decree-Law No. 352/2007 represented an important milestone, as it introduced a Table for the Assessment of Permanent Disabilities in Civil Law, which moves away from the exclusive criterion of earning capacity and instead assesses the person’s overall functional disability. This approach paved the way for the recognition of biological damage within the Portuguese legal system.


The case law of the Supreme Court of Justice has reflected this development. Judgments such as that of 27 October 2009 (Case No. 560/09.0YFLSB, Judge Sebastião Póvoas), that of 20 May 2010 (Case No. 103/2002.L1.S1, Judge Lopes do Rego) and, more recently, those of 12 July 2018 (Case No. 1842/15.8T8STR.E1.S1, Judge Rosa Tching) and 4 July 2023 (Case No. 342/19.1T8PVZ.P1.S1, Judge Jorge Leal), recognised that biological harm may be of a hybrid nature, comprising pecuniary components — such as increased effort at work or the loss of professional opportunities — and non-pecuniary components — such as functional limitation, loss of quality of life or suffering. However, case law is not yet uniform, and there remain variations as to whether this damage should be classified as pecuniary, non-pecuniary or a separate category.


Ministerial Order No. 377/2008, which regulates the framework for the ‘reasonable offer’ to be made by insurers, has added a further layer of complexity. Although its criteria are not binding on the courts, in practice the amounts set out therein have taken on an almost normative character in out-of-court proceedings, often resulting in undercompensation for victims — particularly those without specialist legal advice.


The traditional model of compensation, based on loss of earnings, presents clear risks of commodifying physical and mental integrity. Suffering, loss of autonomy and a deterioration in quality of life cannot be measured in terms of salary. Human dignity, enshrined in Article 1 of the Constitution of the Portuguese Republic, requires that civil liability law recognise and compensate for damages in their human and existential dimensions, and not merely in financial terms.


The recognition of biological harm as a distinct category of damage is, therefore, a necessary and innovative response. It enables us to move beyond the restrictive model based on loss of income, values human beings in their entirety, and promotes a fairer and more egalitarian approach. The Portuguese legal system already possesses the necessary instruments for its full implementation — the scale of incapacity under civil law, the principle of equity set out in Articles 494, 496 and 566 of the Civil Code, and the constitutional protection of personal integrity. What is lacking is doctrinal and case-law clarification, the updating of administrative instruments and, above all, the recognition that truly protecting victims requires acknowledging that all lives are of equal value — regardless of the income they earn.


Una carretera serpenteante rodeada de árboles con hojas de otoño en montañas de fondo.

Related professionals

LATEST FROM #ECIJA