Jane Kirkby explains the implications of the decision regarding the sit-in at Rossio
Jane Kirkby, a partner in the Public Law, Urban Planning, Environment and Energy practice group at Antas da Cunha Ecija, appeared on the Observador’s “Justiça Cega” podcast, where she analysed the decision of the Lisbon Administrative Court regarding Renata Cambra’s right to remain in Rossio with her tent, in protest over housing.
The lawyer explains that, from a legal perspective, the ruling does not extend to the other protesters, as the summons was filed in her own name, without standing to represent the others. She emphasises, however, that the judgement deems the interpretation of the 12.30 am time limit to be unconstitutional, noting that the Government, the Ministry of Internal Affairs (MAI) and the police were already bound by the Constitution, and that the ruling may have a persuasive effect on other protesters to take their cases to court, with each case being assessed on its own merits.
Regarding the actions of the authorities, he argues that the PSP and the Municipal Police must continue to uphold the law and the Constitution, intervening only in the event of non-compliance with the established conditions or an objective danger, and seeking clarification from their superiors in case of doubt. As for the requirement to comply with the law prohibiting the concealment of one’s face at demonstrations, he considers that the judge was less thorough in her reasoning on this point than on the other aspects of the ruling.
Listen to the full episode on Observador
