Isabel Santos Fidalgo: Recovering state aid does not undermine the rule of law
Isabel Santos Fidalgo, a partner in the Tax practice group at Antas da Cunha Ecija, has written an opinion piece for ECO on the recovery of state aid and the Madeira Free Zone litigation.
The lawyer points out that no one disputes the obligation to recover the aid, but questions whether the need for effectiveness can justify tax enforcement outside the rules applicable to any other debt owed to the State. In the light of the Utiledulci judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union, she argues that recovery is an obligation of result rather than of method, and that anything going beyond European criteria, such as the refusal to issue certificates or the reduction of security measures, is a national choice and not an imposition from Brussels.
It also points out that the ten-year limitation period under the European regulation governs the relationship between the Commission and the Member State and cannot, without further ado, be converted into a collection period against the taxpayer. It emphasises the responsibility of national courts to ensure effective judicial protection and concludes that recovery is a duty, but that it only gains legitimacy when it respects safeguards that do not frustrate such recovery.
Read the full article in ECO
