The Weil case: can a law firm sell its clients’ data?
Alonso Hurtado Bueno features in an article in *Expansión* on the legal debate sparked by the insolvency of Weil Gotshal & Manges. The partners of the long-established US firm approved its dissolution with 97 per cent of the vote, and several Spanish law firms, including Crosby, have expressed interest in its assets, ranging from the brand to internal data. The offer raises a question that goes beyond this specific case: what data from a law firm can be bought or sold?
Hurtado distinguishes between the information a firm generates itself – such as databases, proprietary software or methodologies – and that entrusted to it by its clients. Regarding the latter, he emphasises that “a firm holds files, emails, drafts and data relating to specific transactions and advice, but that does not make it the owner”. All such material is covered by professional secrecy and, where identifiable individuals are concerned, also by data protection regulations. The firm’s insolvency does not remove these obligations.
Alonso highlights the differences between the United States and Europe. In the US, there is no general federal data protection law, so in the event of bankruptcy, the sale of personal data is subject only to the restrictions imposed by the company’s privacy policy or professional secrecy. In Europe, by contrast, “the General Data Protection Regulation applies before, during and after insolvency, and any new use of the data requires its own legal basis”.
He also recalls previous cases. When Dewey & LeBoeuf went into liquidation in 2012, nobody sold the client files: an offer was made to return them, and some 345,000 boxes that nobody claimed were eventually destroyed with court authorisation. The report also cites the 2018 case in which the SRA, the regulator of the legal profession in England and Wales, fined a law firm for providing another firm with non-anonymised documents from more than 7,000 files in the context of a potential acquisition. According to the report, the risk is that, as AI multiplies the value of large knowledge bases, the desire to capitalise on this will clash with the trust that information entrusted to a solicitor will not end up in the hands of a third party.
Continue reading the article in Expansión.