Can a company dismiss an employee for refusing to sign a contract addendum?
In a recent judgement establishing consistent case law, dated 30 October 2026 (Case No. 56.819-2024), the Supreme Court sets out important guidelines on the limits of contractual amendments and the circumstances in which an employee’s refusal to accept them may constitute discriminatory dismissal.
What happened?
Forty-eight employees of a supermarket chain were dismissed after refusing to sign contract amendments that changed their job titles from cashiers to shop assistants.
The proposed amendment entailed the loss of financial benefits set out in a current collective agreement.
The employees rejected the change, considering it detrimental to their interests, and were subsequently dismissed on the grounds of the company’s operational needs.
Can a refusal to accept a contractual amendment justify dismissal?
What did the Supreme Court rule?
The Supreme Court concluded that the dismissals constituted acts of employment discrimination, as the continuation of the employment relationship had been made conditional upon the acceptance of detrimental contractual amendments.
In the view of the Supreme Court, the company’s decision infringed the right to non-discrimination, as it used the workers’ refusal as a criterion for terminating their contracts without providing sufficient objective justification.
Consequently, the power to reorganise the company does not permit the continuation of employment to be made conditional upon the acceptance of detrimental contractual changes.
Unfair dismissal or discriminatory dismissal?
The Supreme Court emphasised that the two concepts have different legal bases and consequences.
- Unfair dismissal: This occurs when the termination of the employment relationship lacks a duly substantiated legal ground.
- Discriminatory dismissal: This also involves a distinction or exclusion based on a discriminatory criterion that affects equality of opportunity or treatment in employment.
In this case, the Supreme Court ruled that the dismissal not only lacked sufficient justification but was also based on a discriminatory criterion: the refusal to accept a detrimental contractual amendment.
Why does this matter? In addition to the compensation typically payable in cases of unfair dismissal, the violation of fundamental rights in connection with the dismissal may give rise to additional compensation of between 6 and 11 months’ pay, in accordance with Article 489 of the Labour Code.
Can discrimination exist even if the ground is not expressly set out in the law?
Yes. The Supreme Court reaffirmed that the list of grounds for discrimination set out in Article 2 of the Labour Code is not exhaustive.
Protection also extends to other arbitrary distinctions that affect equality of opportunity or treatment in employment, provided that the elements constituting employment discrimination are present.
In this case, the Supreme Court identified the condition that continued employment be contingent upon the acceptance of a detrimental contractual amendment as a suspect criterion.
This reasoning is particularly relevant given that Act No. 21.643 amended Article 2 of the Labour Code by expressly incorporating a reference to ‘any other ground’ within the categories of discrimination in employment.
To what extent can an employer alter its employees’ duties?
The employer has powers of organisation and management, but these are not unlimited.
As a general rule, changes to the essential terms of the employment contract require the agreement of both parties.
Exceptionally, Article 12 of the Labour Code (‘ius variandi’) allows the employer to unilaterally alter certain conditions, within specific limits, provided that the new duties are similar and there is no detriment to the employee.
In the case under consideration, the proposed change not only altered the duties but also entailed the loss of financial benefits set out in a collective agreement.
The Supreme Court noted that contractual autonomy and the protection of employment rights constitute limits on the exercise of employers’ powers.
What should companies bear in mind?
The ruling provides relevant criteria for managing contractual amendments, reorganisations and terminations:
- Assess the scope of the changes: determine whether they require the employee’s consent or whether they can be implemented within the employer’s legal powers.
- Identify potential adverse effects: review the impact on duties, remuneration, benefits and collective rights.
- Respect the voluntary nature of the agreement: avoid making continued employment conditional upon the acceptance of detrimental contractual amendments.
- Justify terminations: demonstrate objective and independent grounds that justify the termination of the employment relationship, without using the employee’s refusal as the decisive factor.
Read the Supreme Court’s ruling here.