LATEST NEWS: Indefiniteness at the top, rights at stake: the role of the Ombudsman
At a time when it remains unclear who will occupy the post of Ombudsman, this puts the institution back at the centre of public debate and underlines the relevance of its role in the rule of law. It is therefore worth revisiting its origins, competences and practical importance for protecting rights and improving the functioning of the administration.
The Ombudsman occupies - or should occupy - a unique place in the Portuguese legal system as a magistrate of influence, defender of citizens and promoter of good administration. Created in the context of the democratic rule of law that emerged from the 1976 Constitution, it is an independent institution that receives complaints from individuals against the Administration, makes recommendations to correct illegalities and has the prerogative to request a review of the constitutionality of rules.
The Constitution of the Portuguese Republic expressly enshrines it in Article 23 as an independent body, appointed by the Assembly of the Republic, with autonomous action in relation to judicial review and litigation. At the infra-constitutional level, the Ombudsman's Statute is defined by Law no. 9/91, of 9 April, which regulates the appointment, mandate, immunities, powers and duties of cooperation of public entities.
The Ombudsman's core mission is to hear complaints about acts or omissions by public authorities, intervening to prevent or redress injustices. He can make recommendations to correct illegal acts, point out gaps in legislation and issue opinions at the request of the Assembly of the Republic. Its intervention is based on a persuasive and collaborative logic, supported by a strong duty of co-operation on the part of public bodies. It also has the legitimacy to apply to the Constitutional Court for a constitutionality review under the terms of Article 281 of the CRP.
As an extra-judicial "guardian" of fundamental rights, the Ombudsman facilitates citizens' access to a simple, free and swift mechanism of protection against the state, promoting trust in the administration and a culture of legality.
Independence and impartiality are constitutionally guaranteed. The Ombudsman is appointed by a qualified majority of two thirds of the deputies present, serves a four-year term, renewable once, is irremovable and enjoys functional immunities. He is not part of the government and does not decide on disputes, but acts impartially after hearing the organisations concerned.
In short, the Ombudsman is a pillar of the democratic rule of law, ensuring the protection of fundamental rights, the monitoring of administrative legality and the continuous improvement of public administration, remaining a privileged channel for dialogue between citizens and the state.
The current situation of uncertainty over who will occupy the post, regardless of the reasons behind it, is not in the institution's favour and does not do it justice. This institutional instability, coupled with the general public's ignorance of the Ombudsman's existence, competences and modus operandi and the non-binding nature of his recommendations, ends up obliterating a body that, for the sake of justice, deserves a complete redefinition.
