---
title: "The Supreme Court reinforces the right to flexible working hours and requires companies to engage in genuine and effective negotiations"
description: "The Supreme Court has reaffirmed the right to flexible working hours and requires companies to engage in meaningful negotiations."
url: "https://www.ecija.com/en/news-and-insights/the-supreme-court-reinforces-the-right-to-adjusted-working-hours-and-requires-the-company-to-engage-in-genuine-and-effective-negotiations/"
locale: "en-GB"
site: "ECIJA"
image: "https://images.griddo.ecija.com/f/jpg/w/1280/h/768/syed-ayan-malik-di3mlprdyee-unsplash-9aefa129-0f2e-4319-a490-0b93ca6b1802"
rendered: "2026-11-20T11:11:40.609Z"
translations:
  "x-default": "https://www.ecija.com/actualidad-insights/el-tribunal-supremo-refuerza-el-derecho-a-la-adaptacion-de-jornada-y-exige-una-negociacion-real-y-efectiva-por-parte-de-la-empresa/"
  "es-ES": "https://www.ecija.com/actualidad-insights/el-tribunal-supremo-refuerza-el-derecho-a-la-adaptacion-de-jornada-y-exige-una-negociacion-real-y-efectiva-por-parte-de-la-empresa/"
  "en-GB": "https://www.ecija.com/en/news-and-insights/the-supreme-court-reinforces-the-right-to-adjusted-working-hours-and-requires-the-company-to-engage-in-genuine-and-effective-negotiations/"
  "pt-PT": "https://www.ecija.com/pt/noticias-e-informacoes/o-supremo-tribunal-reafirma-o-direito-a-adaptacao-do-horario-de-trabalho-e-exige-que-a-empresa-encete-negociacoes-genuinas-e-eficazes/"
---

## Navigation

- [![Logo ECIJA]()](/en/)
- [About us](https://www.ecija.com/en/about-us/index.md)
- [Trajectory](https://www.ecija.com/en/trajectory/index.md)
- [Awards and Recognitions](https://www.ecija.com/en/awards-and-recognitions/index.md)
- [Purpose and values](https://www.ecija.com/en/purpose-and-values/index.md)
- [Technology, Media and Telecommunications](https://www.ecija.com/en/technology-media-and-telecommunications/index.md)
- [Litigation and Arbitration](https://www.ecija.com/en/litigation-and-arbitration/index.md)
- [Corporate and M&A](https://www.ecija.com/en/corporate-mergers-and-acquisitions/index.md)
- [Employment](https://www.ecija.com/en/employment-law/index.md)
- [Compliance](https://www.ecija.com/en/regulatory-compliance/index.md)
- [All practice areas](https://www.ecija.com/en/capabilities/index.md)
- [News & Insights](https://www.ecija.com/en/news-and-insights/index.md)
- [Talent and Careers](https://www.ecija.com/en/talent-and-careers/index.md)
- [Work with us](https://www.ecija.com/en/trabaja-con-nosotros/index.md)
- [ES](https://www.ecija.com/actualidad-insights/el-tribunal-supremo-refuerza-el-derecho-a-la-adaptacion-de-jornada-y-exige-una-negociacion-real-y-efectiva-por-parte-de-la-empresa/index.md)
- [PT](https://www.ecija.com/pt/noticias-e-informacoes/o-supremo-tribunal-reafirma-o-direito-a-adaptacao-do-horario-de-trabalho-e-exige-que-a-empresa-encete-negociacoes-genuinas-e-eficazes/index.md)
- [Spain](https://www.ecija.com/en/global-coverage/espana/index.md)
- [Portugal](https://adcecija.pt/)
- [All locations](https://www.ecija.com/en/global-coverage/index.md)
- [Contact](https://www.ecija.com/en/contact/index.md)
- [Our team](https://www.ecija.com/en/lawyers/index.md)
- [View full list of professionals](https://www.ecija.com/en/lawyers/index.md)
- [Subscribe](https://www.ecija.com/en/suscripcion-newsletter/index.md)
- [ECIJA Advisory](https://advisory.ecija.com/en/home-2/)
- [Brandbook](https://www.ecija.com/en/ecija-brand-manual/index.md)
- [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/ecija_law/)
- [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/company/ecija/posts/?feedView=all)
- [X](https://x.com/ECIJA)
- [Privacy policy](https://www.ecija.com/en/privacy-policy/index.md)
- [Cookies policy](https://www.ecija.com/en/cookies-policy/index.md)
- [Legal notices](https://www.ecija.com/en/legal-notices/index.md)
- [Governance, management and control system policy](https://www.ecija.com/en/governance-management-and-control-system-policy-governance/index.md)
- [Ethics channel](https://www.ecija.com/en/ethics-channel/index.md)
- [ISO certification](https://www.ecija.com/en/certifications/index.md)

# The Supreme Court reaffirms the right to adjusted working hours and requires the employer to engage in genuine and effective negotiations

[News](https://www.ecija.com/en/news-and-insights/index.md?category=News)30 September 2026

Share

- [LinkedIn](<https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&text=The Supreme Court reinforces the right to flexible working hours and requires companies to engage in genuine and effective negotiations&url=https://www.ecija.com/en/news-and-insights/the-supreme-court-reinforces-the-right-to-adjusted-working-hours-and-requires-the-company-to-engage-in-genuine-and-effective-negotiations/>)

The Supreme Court has upheld the conviction of a mining company for infringing a worker’s right to a work-life balance by rejecting his request to adjust his working hours without following the negotiation process required by Article 34.8 of the Workers’ Statute. The ruling reinforces the legal principle that prior negotiation is an essential requirement, the omission of which may lead to the court granting the requested measure.

*Judgment of the Supreme Court of 9 September 2026*

*(Supreme Court Judgment No. 687/2026, Appeal No. 249/2025).*  

The judgement analyses the scope of employers’ obligations arising from Article 34.8 of the Workers’ Statute regarding the adjustment of working hours for work-life balance purposes. The dispute arose following a request made by an employee, the father of a child under the age of twelve, to change his working hours from a split shift to a continuous morning shift, which would enable him to fulfil his family responsibilities more effectively. The company rejected the request on the grounds of organisational and productivity considerations linked to the managerial duties performed by the employee.

The Supreme Court does not address the dispute from a purely organisational perspective, but rather focuses the debate on the employer’s failure to comply with the legally prescribed procedure for processing requests for working hours adjustments. The Chamber notes that, following the reform introduced by Royal Decree-Law 5/2023, Article 34.8 of the Workers’ Statute establishes a genuine right for employees to request adjustments to their working hours and obliges the employer to initiate a genuine negotiation process lasting a maximum of fifteen days. The judgment emphasises that such negotiation cannot be reduced to a purely formal exercise or a simple refusal. According to the Supreme Court, the legislature intended to establish a genuine process of dialogue based on good faith, aimed at finding solutions that reconcile the worker’s work-life balance needs with the company’s organisational requirements. Consequently, the company cannot simply reject the request by putting forward its own arguments without having first attempted to reach a mutually agreed solution.

![Edificio moderno con ventanas reflectantes bajo un cielo despejado.](https://images.griddo.ecija.com/c/cover/q/70/w/3840/h/1337/p/center/f/jpeg/syed-ayan-malik-di3mlprdyee-unsplash-9aefa129-0f2e-4319-a490-0b93ca6b1802)

The Chamber further emphasises the constitutional dimension of work-life balance rights, which are linked both to the principle of equality and to the protection of the family and children, as recognised in Articles 14 and 39 of the Constitution. From this perspective, the provisions promoting work-life balance must be interpreted in a manner that offers particular safeguards, giving precedence to their protective purpose.

Applying these criteria to the specific case, the Court concludes that the company failed to fulfil its legal obligation to negotiate. Although it requested further information and subsequently issued a reasoned response, it did not carry out the genuine negotiation process required by law, nor did it propose alternatives capable of meeting the work-life balance needs raised by the employee. The company’s conduct was, in essence, limited to a unilateral refusal.

The judgement also reaffirms a principle of particular relevance to business practice: where a company fails to follow the negotiation process required by Article 34.8 of the Workers’ Statute, the usual consequence will be the court’s upholding of the measure sought by the employee. This outcome may only be set aside where the request is manifestly unreasonable or clearly disproportionate in relation to the organisational needs demonstrated by the company.

In the case under consideration, the Court found that the request made by the employee reflected a genuine need for a work-life balance and was not, on the face of it, abusive or disproportionate. Consequently, it upholds the ruling of the High Court of Justice of Asturias, which had found a breach of the right to a work-life balance and awarded compensation of 7,501 euros for non-pecuniary damage.

This ruling thus consolidates a line of case law that is increasingly demanding of employers in matters of work-life balance, reinforcing the obligation to negotiate effectively regarding requests for adjustments to working hours and making such negotiations a central element in determining the validity of the employer’s decision.

## Related professionals

## LATEST FROM #ECIJA