---
title: "LATEST NEWS: Between formality and justice: can the Tax Authority breach the law without compensating the taxpayer?"
description: "The debate over whether the Tax Authority may breach the law without compensating the taxpayer."
url: "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/latest-news-between-formality-and-justice-can-the-tax-authority-break-the-law-without-compensating-the-taxpayer/"
locale: "en-GB"
site: "Portugal"
rendered: "2026-11-20T11:12:18.661Z"
translations:
  "x-default": "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/latest-news-entre-a-formalidade-e-a-justica-pode-a-autoridade-tributaria-violar-a-lei-sem-indemnizar-o-contribuinte/"
  "es-ES": "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/esp/ultimas-noticias-entre-la-formalidad-y-la-justicia-puede-la-administracion-tributaria-infringir-la-ley-sin-indemnizar-al-contribuyente/"
  "en-GB": "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/latest-news-between-formality-and-justice-can-the-tax-authority-break-the-law-without-compensating-the-taxpayer/"
  "pt-PT": "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/latest-news-entre-a-formalidade-e-a-justica-pode-a-autoridade-tributaria-violar-a-lei-sem-indemnizar-o-contribuinte/"
---

## Navigation

- [![Logo ECIJA Portugal](//assets.griddo.ecija.com/pro-ecija/static/logo-ecija-pt-66e5bebc974f6f64c0ffde8580f5f214.png)](/adcecija/en/)
- [About us](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/about/index.md)
- [AI Manifesto](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/ai-manifesto/index.md)
- [Awards and recognitions](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/awards-recognitions/index.md)
- [ESG purpose](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/esg-purpose/index.md)
- [Trajectory](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/trajectory/index.md)
- [Commercial, Corporate & M&A](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/commercial-corporate-ma-pt/index.md)
- [Criminal, Misdemeanor & Compliance](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/criminal-misdemeanor-compliance-pt/index.md)
- [Digital Contracting & Compliance](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/digital-contracting-compliance-pt/index.md)
- [European Union & Competition](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/european-union-competition-pt/index.md)
- [Family, Successions & Family Businesses](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/family-successions-family-businesses-pt/index.md)
- [Immigration & Citizenship](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/immigration-citizenship-pt/index.md)
- [Insurance & Civil Liability](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/insurance-civil-liability-pt/index.md)
- [Labour & Social Security](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/labour-social-security-pt/index.md)
- [Life Sciences & Healthcare](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/life-sciences-and-healthcare-pt/index.md)
- [Litigation & Arbitration](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/litigation-arbitration-pt/index.md)
- [Real Estate](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/real-estate-pt/index.md)
- [Sports, Fashion, Media & Entertainment](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/sports-fashion-media-entertainment-pt/index.md)
- [Public Law, Planning, Environment & Energy](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/public-law-planning-environment-energy-pt/index.md)
- [Tax](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/tax-pt/index.md)
- [See all](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/services/index.md)
- [Team](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/team/index.md)
- [Insights](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/insights/index.md)
- [People and Culture](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/people-culture/index.md)
- [ES](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/esp/ultimas-noticias-entre-la-formalidad-y-la-justicia-puede-la-administracion-tributaria-infringir-la-ley-sin-indemnizar-al-contribuyente/index.md)
- [PT](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/latest-news-entre-a-formalidade-e-a-justica-pode-a-autoridade-tributaria-violar-a-lei-sem-indemnizar-o-contribuinte/index.md)
- [Portugal](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/portugal/index.md)
- [Spain](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/spain/index.md)
- [See all](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/international-presence/index.md)
- [Contact](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/contact-us/index.md)
- [Subscribe](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/newsletter/index.md)
- [Insights](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/insights-research/index.md)
- [Applications](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/people-culture/index.md#estagios)
- [Brandbook](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/brandbook/index.md)
- [Events](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/event-finder/index.md)
- [+351 21 319 2080](tel:+351 21 319 2080)
- [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/company/antasdacunhaecija/)
- [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/antasdacunhaecija/)
- [YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/@antasdacunhaecija)
- [Privacy policy](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/politica-de-privacidade/index.md)
- [Cookies policy](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/politica-de-cookies/index.md)
- [![La imagen presenta logotipos de programas y financiación de la Unión Europea y del gobierno portugués.](https://images.griddo.ecija.com/c/cover/q/75/w/3865/h/396/f/jpeg/barra-logos-49887971-d295-4481-8fe2-1dd6e4fc5e89 "barra-logos")](/adcecija/en/recovery-resilience-plan/)

# LATEST NEWS: Between formality and justice: can the Tax Authority breach the law without compensating the taxpayer?

[Articles](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/index.md?category=Articles)29 September 2026

Share

- [LinkedIn](<https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&text=LATEST NEWS: Between formality and justice: can the Tax Authority breach the law without compensating the taxpayer?&url=https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/latest-news-between-formality-and-justice-can-the-tax-authority-break-the-law-without-compensating-the-taxpayer/>)

The award of compensatory interest to a taxpayer whose claim has been upheld by the Tax Authority or the courts has been the subject of extensive discussion in case law.

Article 43(1) of the General Tax Law (LGT) recognises interest where there is an ‘error attributable to the tax authorities’ and, for this purpose, case law distinguishes between substantive irregularities and procedural defects: where an assessment is annulled due to an error in the factual or legal premises, the right to compensatory interest tends to be recognised. Conversely, where the annulment is based on procedural defects, such as a lack of reasoning or a prior hearing, the right tends to be denied.

The Supreme Administrative Court (STA) has repeatedly held that formal defects do not, in themselves, demonstrate that the tax liability was materially unjustified (see judgment of 4 November 2020, case no. 037/19.6BALSB, reaffirmed by the judgment of 24 June 2026, case no. 013/26.2BALSB). In our view, this approach warrants reconsideration.

This distinction leads to a paradoxical result, in that inadequate reasoning may reveal an error and give rise to interest, whilst its complete absence is treated as a mere procedural defect, thereby precluding such interest. Thus, the less the Tax Authority (AT) substantiates its decision – in clear violation of taxpayers’ rights – the lower its financial liability may be.

An identical problem arises in relation to the expiry of the right to issue an assessment, where the STA has accepted that an assessment issued after the deadline is not sufficient to give rise to compensatory interest (see judgment of 24 June 2026, case no. 013/26.2BALSB). However, if the Tax Authority (AT) was no longer able to issue an assessment, the action that led to the assessment should not be financially neutral, since the expiry of the limitation period is a legal limit on the power to assess, which must be respected.

The same applies to the situation regarding the preliminary hearing, insofar as allowing the taxpayer to present potentially decisive facts and evidence is essential to the procedure and to sound administration; therefore, if its omission contributed to upholding an assessment that could have been avoided or corrected, it should not be deemed irrelevant for the purposes of compensation. Nevertheless, case law continues to classify it as a procedural defect (see the Supreme Tax Court judgement of 3 June 2026, case no. 0638/18.0BELRS).

In this context, the proposal by the Commission for the Review of Tax Processes and Procedures and Taxpayers’ Guarantees takes on particular significance; it amends Article 43(1) of the General Tax Law (LGT), where, instead of requiring an ‘error attributable to the tax authorities’, it proposes the award of interest whenever there is an error not attributable to the taxpayer which results in a payment in excess of the amount legally due.

The amendment is not merely semantic: errors not attributable to the taxpayer would always be attributed to the Tax Authority (AT), regardless of the officials’ fault, whilst the regime would remain limited to timely responses, and the taxpayer’s inaction could be regarded as fault on the part of the aggrieved party.

The solution shifts the focus from the formal or substantive classification of the defect to the existence of an unlawful act by the Tax Authority, not attributable to the taxpayer, which has resulted in a payment in excess of the amount due.

This is not a matter of turning interest into an automatic penalty: the requirements of an undue payment, a relevant illegality and a causal link between the administrative action and the financial loss would still apply. It would, however, prevent the formal classification of the defect from, in itself, determining the right to compensation.

A legislative amendment or a new interpretation of ‘error attributable to the authorities’ would prevent the Tax Authority from benefiting from the omission or negligence of its officials. It is inconsistent that a failure to comply with the duty to state reasons, the duty to hold a prior hearing, or the prohibition on making a settlement after the expiry of the limitation period should be financially advantageous compared to merely deficient compliance with those duties.

The question therefore remains: can the Tax Authority commit an unlawful act, cause or perpetuate financial loss, and avoid paying interest simply because the defect was classified as a procedural one? The affirmative answer is predominant in current case law. However, the proposed amendment to Article 43(1) of the LGT and/or a possible new interpretation of ‘error attributable to the authorities’ show that this is not the only legally possible answer, nor is it necessarily the fairest in light of the Tax Authority’s legal obligations.

![Una mano escribe en un papel con billetes de euro esparcidos sobre la mesa.](https://images.griddo.ecija.com/c/cover/q/70/w/3840/h/1337/p/center/f/jpeg/jakub-zerdzicki-vbfvthpcovw-unsplash-ba0780b5-dc40-4fd6-9d69-bef63ae14873)

## Related professionals

## LATEST FROM #ECIJA