---
title: "Jane Kirkby comments on the deadlock in the Constitutional Court election"
description: "Jane Kirkby analyzes the deadlock in the Constitutional Court election and its legal implications."
url: "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/jane-kirkby-comenta-impasse-na-eleicao-do-tribunal-constitucional/"
locale: "en-GB"
site: "Portugal"
rendered: "2026-11-20T11:12:11.025Z"
translations:
  "x-default": "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/jane-kirkby-comenta-impasse-na-eleicao-do-tribunal-constitucional/"
  "es-ES": "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/esp/jane-kirkby-comenta-impasse-na-eleicao-do-tribunal-constitucional/"
  "en-GB": "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/jane-kirkby-comenta-impasse-na-eleicao-do-tribunal-constitucional/"
  "pt-PT": "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/jane-kirkby-comenta-impasse-na-eleicao-do-tribunal-constitucional/"
---

## Navigation

- [![Logo ECIJA Portugal](//assets.griddo.ecija.com/pro-ecija/static/logo-ecija-pt-66e5bebc974f6f64c0ffde8580f5f214.png)](/adcecija/en/)
- [About us](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/about/index.md)
- [AI Manifesto](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/ai-manifesto/index.md)
- [Awards and recognitions](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/awards-recognitions/index.md)
- [ESG purpose](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/esg-purpose/index.md)
- [Trajectory](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/trajectory/index.md)
- [Commercial, Corporate & M&A](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/commercial-corporate-ma-pt/index.md)
- [Criminal, Misdemeanor & Compliance](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/criminal-misdemeanor-compliance-pt/index.md)
- [Digital Contracting & Compliance](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/digital-contracting-compliance-pt/index.md)
- [European Union & Competition](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/european-union-competition-pt/index.md)
- [Family, Successions & Family Businesses](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/family-successions-family-businesses-pt/index.md)
- [Immigration & Citizenship](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/immigration-citizenship-pt/index.md)
- [Insurance & Civil Liability](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/insurance-civil-liability-pt/index.md)
- [Labour & Social Security](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/labour-social-security-pt/index.md)
- [Life Sciences & Healthcare](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/life-sciences-and-healthcare-pt/index.md)
- [Litigation & Arbitration](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/litigation-arbitration-pt/index.md)
- [Real Estate](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/real-estate-pt/index.md)
- [Sports, Fashion, Media & Entertainment](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/sports-fashion-media-entertainment-pt/index.md)
- [Public Law, Planning, Environment & Energy](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/public-law-planning-environment-energy-pt/index.md)
- [Tax](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/tax-pt/index.md)
- [See all](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/services/index.md)
- [Team](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/team/index.md)
- [Insights](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/insights/index.md)
- [People and Culture](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/people-culture/index.md)
- [ES](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/esp/jane-kirkby-comenta-impasse-na-eleicao-do-tribunal-constitucional/index.md)
- [PT](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/jane-kirkby-comenta-impasse-na-eleicao-do-tribunal-constitucional/index.md)
- [Portugal](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/portugal/index.md)
- [Spain](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/spain/index.md)
- [See all](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/international-presence/index.md)
- [Contact](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/contact-us/index.md)
- [Subscribe](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/newsletter/index.md)
- [Insights](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/insights-research/index.md)
- [Applications](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/people-culture/index.md#estagios)
- [Brandbook](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/brandbook/index.md)
- [Events](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/event-finder/index.md)
- [+351 21 319 2080](tel:+351 21 319 2080)
- [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/company/antasdacunhaecija/)
- [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/antasdacunhaecija/)
- [YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/@antasdacunhaecija)
- [Privacy policy](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/politica-de-privacidade/index.md)
- [Cookies policy](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/politica-de-cookies/index.md)
- [![La imagen presenta logotipos de programas y financiación de la Unión Europea y del gobierno portugués.](https://images.griddo.ecija.com/c/cover/q/75/w/3865/h/396/f/jpeg/barra-logos-49887971-d295-4481-8fe2-1dd6e4fc5e89 "barra-logos")](/adcecija/en/recovery-resilience-plan/)

# Jane Kirkby comments on the deadlock in the Constitutional Court election

[News](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/index.md?category=News)23 March 2026

Share

- [LinkedIn](<https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&text=Jane Kirkby comments on the deadlock in the Constitutional Court election&url=https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/jane-kirkby-comenta-impasse-na-eleicao-do-tribunal-constitucional/>)

In an article published in ECO, Jane Kirkby, a partner in the Public Law Department at Antas da Cunha Ecija, analyses the current impasse in appointments to the Constitutional Court, in the light of the model of qualified majorities laid down in the Constitution.

The lawyer emphasises that, in constitutional terms, "the Portuguese model is working as it was designed", explaining that the requirement for broad consensus aims to protect the independence of bodies such as the Constitutional Court, preventing them from being captured by cyclical majorities.

Jane Kirkby recognises, however, that the current context of parliamentary fragmentation makes it more difficult to reach these consensuses, and also points out that although the qualified majority is an essential instrument of institutional protection, in practice it can encourage cross-veto dynamics when there is no culture of compromise between the parties.

The lawyer also argues that there is room to improve the functioning of the system in terms of parliamentary procedures, namely through greater predictability, transparency and accountability, without compromising the independence of the institutions.

Read the full article here: [ECO](https://eco.sapo.pt/2026/03/20/eleicao-para-o-constitucional-rompe-bloco-central-orcamento-nao-e-moeda-de-troca-mas-havera-consequencias/ "https://eco.sapo.pt/2026/03/18/trump-derruba-pedra-angular-da-lei-climatica-dos-eua-e-atinge-esforcos-globais/")

![La imagen muestra un interior de una sala con bancos de madera dispuestos en filas.](https://images.griddo.ecija.com/c/cover/q/70/w/3840/h/1337/p/center/f/jpeg/kelly-sikkema-1yeql23dvji-unsplash-0887a112-ec10-4fb8-b6fb-8275fb631769)

## Related professionals

## LATEST FROM #ECIJA