---
title: "Flash Alert: The STJ rules that the conversion of advances into supplementary instalments is null and void"
description: "The STJ has ruled that the conversion of advances into supplementary instalments is null and void."
url: "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/flash-alert-the-stj-declares-the-conversion-of-advances-into-supplementary-payments-to-be-null-and-void/"
locale: "en-GB"
site: "Portugal"
rendered: "2026-11-20T11:12:20.915Z"
translations:
  "x-default": "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/flash-alert-o-stj-declara-nulidade-da-conversao-de-suprimentos-em-prestacoes-suplementares/"
  "es-ES": "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/esp/flash-alert-el-stj-dictamina-que-la-conversion-de-los-anticipos-en-cuotas-complementarias-es-nula-y-sin-efecto/"
  "en-GB": "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/flash-alert-the-stj-declares-the-conversion-of-advances-into-supplementary-payments-to-be-null-and-void/"
  "pt-PT": "https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/flash-alert-o-stj-declara-nulidade-da-conversao-de-suprimentos-em-prestacoes-suplementares/"
---

## Navigation

- [![Logo ECIJA Portugal](//assets.griddo.ecija.com/pro-ecija/static/logo-ecija-pt-66e5bebc974f6f64c0ffde8580f5f214.png)](/adcecija/en/)
- [About us](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/about/index.md)
- [AI Manifesto](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/ai-manifesto/index.md)
- [Awards and recognitions](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/awards-recognitions/index.md)
- [ESG purpose](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/esg-purpose/index.md)
- [Trajectory](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/trajectory/index.md)
- [Commercial, Corporate & M&A](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/commercial-corporate-ma-pt/index.md)
- [Criminal, Misdemeanor & Compliance](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/criminal-misdemeanor-compliance-pt/index.md)
- [Digital Contracting & Compliance](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/digital-contracting-compliance-pt/index.md)
- [European Union & Competition](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/european-union-competition-pt/index.md)
- [Family, Successions & Family Businesses](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/family-successions-family-businesses-pt/index.md)
- [Immigration & Citizenship](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/immigration-citizenship-pt/index.md)
- [Insurance & Civil Liability](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/insurance-civil-liability-pt/index.md)
- [Labour & Social Security](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/labour-social-security-pt/index.md)
- [Life Sciences & Healthcare](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/life-sciences-and-healthcare-pt/index.md)
- [Litigation & Arbitration](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/litigation-arbitration-pt/index.md)
- [Real Estate](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/real-estate-pt/index.md)
- [Sports, Fashion, Media & Entertainment](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/sports-fashion-media-entertainment-pt/index.md)
- [Public Law, Planning, Environment & Energy](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/public-law-planning-environment-energy-pt/index.md)
- [Tax](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/tax-pt/index.md)
- [See all](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/services/index.md)
- [Team](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/team/index.md)
- [Insights](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/insights/index.md)
- [People and Culture](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/people-culture/index.md)
- [ES](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/esp/flash-alert-el-stj-dictamina-que-la-conversion-de-los-anticipos-en-cuotas-complementarias-es-nula-y-sin-efecto/index.md)
- [PT](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/flash-alert-o-stj-declara-nulidade-da-conversao-de-suprimentos-em-prestacoes-suplementares/index.md)
- [Portugal](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/portugal/index.md)
- [Spain](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/spain/index.md)
- [See all](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/international-presence/index.md)
- [Contact](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/contact-us/index.md)
- [Subscribe](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/newsletter/index.md)
- [Insights](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/insights-research/index.md)
- [Applications](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/people-culture/index.md#estagios)
- [Brandbook](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/brandbook/index.md)
- [Events](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/event-finder/index.md)
- [+351 21 319 2080](tel:+351 21 319 2080)
- [LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/company/antasdacunhaecija/)
- [Instagram](https://www.instagram.com/antasdacunhaecija/)
- [YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/@antasdacunhaecija)
- [Privacy policy](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/politica-de-privacidade/index.md)
- [Cookies policy](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/politica-de-cookies/index.md)
- [![La imagen presenta logotipos de programas y financiación de la Unión Europea y del gobierno portugués.](https://images.griddo.ecija.com/c/cover/q/75/w/3865/h/396/f/jpeg/barra-logos-49887971-d295-4481-8fe2-1dd6e4fc5e89 "barra-logos")](/adcecija/en/recovery-resilience-plan/)

# Flash Alert: The STJ declares the conversion of advances into supplementary instalments to be null and void

[Articles](https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/index.md?category=Articles)27 October 2026

Share

- [LinkedIn](<https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&text=Flash Alert: The STJ rules that the conversion of advances into supplementary instalments is null and void&url=https://www.ecija.com/adcecija/en/flash-alert-the-stj-declares-the-conversion-of-advances-into-supplementary-payments-to-be-null-and-void/>)

Judgment of the Supreme Court of Justice of 15 September 2026, Case No. 6307/24.4T8VNG.P1.S1

In a judgement of 15 September 2026, the Supreme Court of Justice (“STJ”) unanimously declared null and void a company resolution that allowed a shareholder to fulfil their share of additional capital contributions by converting advances. The decision thus calls into question a widespread practice in the strengthening of companies’ equity capital.

**I. Background**

Advances made by shareholders constitute a fairly common form of financing for commercial companies, sometimes taking a more formal form through the conclusion of advance agreements, and at other times a more informal form through mere advances of funds recorded in the accounts.

It is also common for shareholders, prior to the repayment of such advances, to convert them into supplementary contributions, so that the amounts in question come to be regarded as the company’s equity capital.

In the context of the case in question, the matter under discussion was a resolution of the general meeting of a public limited company whose articles of association permitted the requirement of supplementary contributions from shareholders. Through this resolution, supplementary contributions totalling €329,000 were required, to be apportioned in proportion to the shareholders’ respective shareholdings. Whilst the minority shareholders were required to make their contributions in cash, the majority shareholder was to make her contribution, amounting to €172,975.81, ‘by way of conversion, with the inherent waiver of the right to reimbursement, of advances in that same amount’.

The Supreme Court of Justice (STJ) declared this corporate resolution null and void, overturning the decision of the Porto Court of Appeal.

**II. Grounds for the decision**

a) Application of the rules on supplementary contributions to public limited companies

The STJ accepted the analogous application of Articles 210 to 213 of the Commercial Companies Code (‘CSC’) to public limited companies, provided that the shareholders provide for supplementary contributions in the articles of association and subject them to that regime. Once the supplementary contributions regime has been chosen, it applies in full; it is not permissible to avail oneself only of its favourable effects whilst disregarding the rules relating to the purpose and manner of fulfilment of the contribution.

b) The conversion of capital contributions does not constitute a transfer of cash

In the view of the STJ, when converting advances, the shareholder “does not deliver cash, but rather utilises or extinguishes a claim that he held against the company itself”. The Court refrained from classifying the transaction as a remission, waiver, payment in kind or set-off, as it considered that the result is, in any event, identical: the company does not receive cash and the partner discharges his obligation at the expense of a claim to which he was already entitled. The transaction is therefore invalid under either of the two possible interpretations:

- if the claim constitutes the very subject-matter of the consideration, this would amount to an asset other than money, in breach of Article 210(2) of the CSC, according to which supplementary considerations “must always have money as their subject-matter”. In the Court’s words, the law “requires an object. It is this that is lacking”. Indeed, a claim against the company is not money, even if it is expressed in euros, a point which the Court of Appeal itself ultimately recognised by subjecting the transaction to the valuation of contributions in kind (Article 28 of the CSC);
- if, on the other hand, the resolution creates a pecuniary obligation to be fulfilled by means of a credit for capital contributions, this breaches the prohibition on set-off enshrined in Article 212(2) of the CSC. In the view of the Supreme Court of Justice (STJ), set-off against advances is precisely the paradigmatic example that this prohibition is intended to prevent: a shareholder who is simultaneously a debtor in respect of capital contributions and a creditor of the company may not extinguish one obligation by setting it off against the other. If the transaction amounts to releasing the partner from the obligation to make contributions, paragraph 3 of the same provision is also breached, as it prohibits the company from exonerating the partner.

The Supreme Court of Justice (STJ) emphasised the mandatory nature of these rules: neither the shareholder nor the company may, by agreement or resolution, substitute the payment of cash with the use of a claim against the company. Nor does it matter that the set-off is provided for in the resolution itself which requires the contributions, rather than being declared subsequently by the shareholder; for ‘the mere reversal of the sequence of acts’ is sufficient to achieve the result prohibited by law. The Court, moreover, likened this solution to the regime governing capital contributions (Article 27 of the CSC), where the same logic applies: the company must receive actual cash, and not merely the extinguishment of a liability.

c) Irrelevance of the monetary origin of capital contributions

The STJ rejected the central argument on which the Court of Appeal’s judgment was based. The adverb ‘always’ contained in Article 210(2), combined with the express prohibition on set-off, prevents the monetary origin of the capital injections from being regarded as sufficient. The money entered the company as an interest-bearing loan, giving rise to a claim for repayment, and it is this claim, and not the money itself, that is mobilised at the time of the resolution. The conversion eliminates a liability, but this effect ‘does not alter the legal nature of the asset nor convert the claim into currency’.

(d) Inapplicability of the regime governing capital increases through the conversion of capital contributions

The exemption from the statutory auditor’s report in the case of a capital increase through the conversion of advances (Article 89(4) of the CSC) constitutes a special regime, which does not equate the claim with cash: even in the case of a capital increase, the conversion still constitutes a contribution in kind. The Court also rejected the argument based on the principle of majority rule, noting that creditors may demand the realisation of capital contributions (Article 30 of the CSC), but not of supplementary contributions (Article 212(4) of the CSC). There is therefore no single scale of protection that would allow one regime to be transposed into the other.

The STJ further distinguished this transaction from a pure and simple waiver of supplementary contributions: those who waive receive nothing in return, whereas those who ‘convert’ retain a contingent right to the restitution of supplementary contributions (Article 213 of the CSC), for the full nominal value of the extinguished claim.

**III. Conclusion**

It follows from this judgment that any resolution providing for the payment of supplementary instalments through the conversion of advances is null and void, even if such advances are of a monetary nature. In the view of the STJ, supplementary contributions always have money as their object and the company must receive actual cash, rather than the mere extinguishment of a liability; the rules prohibiting set-off and the exoneration of the shareholder are mandatory. Given the frequency with which shareholders resort to this conversion to strengthen companies’ equity capital, the decision takes on particular practical significance, as it calls into question a solution that is widespread throughout the business world.

![Un mazo de juez de madera sobre una superficie de madera.](https://images.griddo.ecija.com/c/cover/q/70/w/3840/h/1337/p/center/f/jpeg/wesley-tingey-9z9fxr-7z-k-unsplash-6fdddfbe-852a-434f-9f3b-fc07db793739)

## Related professionals

## LATEST FROM #ECIJA